Wine cellar interior
Since Day One · Park Slope, Brooklyn

Brooklyn's
finest spirits
found on
5th Avenue

From small-batch bourbons to Old World wines, Bay River Wine & Liquors curates an extraordinary selection for the discerning palate — right here in the heart of Park Slope.

Explore Collection Our Story
539 5th Ave, Brooklyn
1-718-768-5402
Scroll
The Collection

A World of Flavor

Every bottle tells a story. From the sun-drenched hills of Tuscany to the misty distilleries of Scotland, we bring you the world's most celebrated and hidden-gem spirits.

Red wine collection
Signature

Wine

Reds, whites, rosés, and sparkling — from Napa Valley to Burgundy, each bottle hand-selected for quality and character.

Explore
Premium spirits collection
Premium

Spirits

Single-malt Scotch, small-batch bourbon, artisanal tequila, and craft gin — the rarest finds for the serious collector.

Explore
Craft beer selection
Local & Rare

Craft Beer

Brooklyn brews, import lagers, and seasonal releases — rotating selections that celebrate both local craft and international tradition.

Explore
Bay River Wine & Liquors store interior
5th
Avenue
11215
Brooklyn
Our Story

More than a liquor store — a neighborhood institution

Bay River Wine & Liquors sits at the crossroads of Park Slope's vibrant community and Brooklyn's rich culinary heritage. Located on 5th Avenue, we've been a trusted destination for wine enthusiasts, cocktail connoisseurs, and everyday New Yorkers seeking something special.

Our shelves are stocked with an ever-evolving selection — from everyday favorites to hard-to-find imports, rare vintages, and small-batch spirits that you won't discover at a big-box store. We know our customers by name and take genuine pride in helping you find exactly what you're looking for.

Expert Guidance
Knowledgeable staff
Curated Selection
Hand-picked bottles
Local & Import
Brooklyn + world wines
Special Orders
We'll find it for you
The Experience

Why Brooklyn chooses us

We're not just a store — we're your destination for discovering something extraordinary in every bottle.

Trusted Quality

Every bottle meets our standards. We source directly from wineries and distilleries to guarantee authenticity and freshness.

Always Open

Seven days a week, we're here when you need us. Extended hours to fit your schedule — because great spirits wait for no one.

Rare Finds

Looking for that special bottle for a milestone? We specialize in hard-to-find labels, vintage vintages, and limited releases.

Personal Touch

We remember your name and your preferences. Whether it's a weekly staple or a once-a-year gift, we make it personal.

Wine rack display
Craft cocktail
Spirits shelf
Champagne selection
Visit Us

Come say hello

We're right here on 5th Avenue in Park Slope — easy to find, impossible to forget. Stop by anytime and let us help you discover your next favorite bottle.

Address
539 5th Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11215-4808
Hours
Mon – Sat: 9:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sunday: 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Map showing Bay River Wine & Liquors location in Brooklyn
Bay River Wine & Liquors
539 5th Ave, Brooklyn 11215
Directions
Prefer to call?
We're happy to help you find exactly what you need.
Call Now
What's Next

Your next favorite bottle is waiting

Whether you're planning a celebration, building your home bar, or simply treating yourself — we're here to help you find the perfect pour.

Call 1-718-768-5402 Get Directions
Is this your business? This is my business